1701 Sunrise Highway

Bay Shore NY 11706


in Bay Shore NY

These reviews have been excerpted from Yelp! (Yelp is an international website where consumers everywhere post their experiences and their reviews of businesses operating in their local areas. To see more reviews of this business, use a good search engine, such as Google, and into the search box key in- Old Country Buffet Complaints

Kim W. Lake Grove NY: I wouldn't even give it a star. The beginning of my experience went very well until we came back to the table and found a cockroach on the table. I feel so sick everytime I think of it barffff...

Brenda F. Bay Shore NY: So here's the deal this place used to be good and now has gone downhill. The food isn't really that great...I saw kids dipping their hands in some of toppings for the ice cream( not sanitary at all)

Joe E. Port St. Lucie FL: the worst, we had lunch the soup was cold the place was filthy. salad bar had other stuff mixed in not appetizing @ all never again. they need a few good managers running that dump.

Jeremy L.Copiague NY: DO NOT COME HERE!! This place is terrible, I've been coming here for 10 years and the food used to taste halfway desent (sic) but now the food tastes really really bad. DO NOT COME HERE!!

Adrian C. Elmhurst NY: No good place food is terrible and so small variation in the buffet area , dessert are the same nothing good looks really old

Nick R. Bethpage NY: Could have more selection of food meaning better things like burgers and ribs all meat stuff and the ice cream machine is broken I don't know If I could come back.

Christine D. Islip NY: I went to this location when it opened. It was really nice and clean as well as the food was good. I recently went back and it was filthy. The carpet is so stained that you stick to it. The plates are all scratched up and the silverware looks like it went through a war in the dishwasher. The dessert bar had very little in the way of selection and was covered in a mess. The cones for the ice cream were empty and I was not able to find someone to let them know. The food was marginal tasting at best but I honestly was so nervous about eating anything because I was afraid I might get sick since the place was so dirty. The decaf coffee was so watery, it was undrinkable. The waiters/waitresses were working so hard because it was busy. I used to buy gift cards but I will not be anymore. Overall, a very disappointing and sad experience.

More? http://www.old-country-buffet.pissedconsumer.com/complaints.html

Click to return back to the page you just came from!